Metal Detectors and Concealment
A friend asked an interesting question the other day.
“So at a movie screening they sometimes use metal detectors on all going in. How does that effect my carry status?”
In this situation there is no posting compliant with 30.06 of the penal code, however we still have an obligation to maintain concealment. As a rule, concealed means that nobody knows you have it. More in keeping with the law, however, a person commits an offense if he INTENTIONALLY fails to conceal a handgun.
There are four states of criminal culpability which are, from greatest to least, intentionally, knowingly, recklessly, or with criminal negligence.
PC 6.03(a) states:
A person acts intentionally, or with intent, with respect to the
nature of his conduct or to a result of his conduct when it is his
conscious objective or desire to engage in the conduct or cause the
result.
According to the letter of the law a CHL holder who allows himself to be wanded and his firearm discovered would, probably, at most, be in the Knowing mental state. This does not meet the required culpability of “intentionally”, therefor I would say that it would not be an offense under Unlawful Carrying of a Weapon by a License Holder (UCWLH). It might, however, be considered an offense under the disorderly conduct statute, as it would probably cause a disturbance when the security guard finds the weapon.
In fact, you are intentionally submitting to the search, so a UCWLH charge may stick. Otherwise, you’ll plea it down to disorderly conduct, and loose your CHL anyway.
Are we talking about hard jail time here? No. But what we are talking about is probably loosing your CHL, and a lot of legal expenses, not to mention a nice matching set of bracelets and a free ride downtown.
Has anyone been convicted of that, specifically? I don’t know. Can they be? It depends on how much the jury likes you. Should they be? Quite probably.
Granted, the purpose of having someone with a metal detector out front is generally not to detect law abiding citizens who have elected to equip themselves with tools of defense. It is more likely that they are there to prevent some form of actual miscreant from entering their property.
Does it make complete and total sense? No. But guess what? It’s their property, they get to decide what goes on there. If they wish to bar the legal and responsible possession of firearms on their premises, that’s up to them to decide. I think I’ve heard more people complain about that than I have heard people complain about being told to turn their cell phone off in a theater. At least there are laws to support them barring CHL carry…
Just my $0.02…
-Head


